DO WE NEED NEWER ANTIHYPERTENSIVES?

The million-dollar question in hypertension is the problem of diagnosis. In my opinion there is nothing called essential hypertension. Every single patient with persistent hypertension has a cause. It may not always be detectable in the body or in the phenotypic investigations that we do. The cause could even be in the mind, which forms about thirty per cent of man. To predict the future course in man one should know the total initial state of man. In the present context it is near nigh impossible. That being the case there is no point in going on drugging patients with newer blood pressure lowering drugs most of whom have now been known to have deleterious side effects in the long run. Followed up for a long time almost all well controlled hypertensives had increased mortality compared to their normotensive cousins!1 The old dictum that the “war is too serious a matter to be left to the generals alone” could be applied here very aptly thus: ”Hypertension is too complicated a matter to be decided on the spot by doctors alone, without due concern for the human being’s total environment”.



Many a time, the numbers he records might alarm the practitioner himself and, he could draw wrong conclusions, in the first place. If only the doctor could sit back, take a couple of deep breaths, and then listen carefully to the patient’s woes, trying to soothe his frayed nerves; the next recording of the pressure could even have come down so much that the patient could not possibly be labeled hypertensive at that time! This scenario is not rare, as many would want to believe.



Even after repeated checking of blood pressures over a period of three months, to make a diagnosis of mild-moderate hypertension, in the famous Australasian study, half the patients became normotensive on placebo alone,2 over a period of next three more months. All that could have changed their diagnosis, would be the tender loving care of the research team. A recent meta-alaysis of the six major journals reporting anti-hypertensive treatment studies, revealed that all of them had flaws in the method of checking blood pressure.



The gravity of the diagnostic dilemma must be clearer to the reader by now. To add to the doctors’ problems is the fact that hypertension, per se, is not a disease. It is, at best, a risk factor for future degenerative diseases, like stroke, heart attack, renal failure, and retinal diseases. Here we are on a very wet wicket. Predicting the future in a dynamic system, like the human body is an impossibility, unless we have the total knowledge of the initial state of the organism3. The latter is impossible at the present time. Man consists of his phenotype (of which we know something, viz. blood pressure level etc.), his genotype (of which we know nothing at the moment), and his mind or consciousness (which has been found to play the most decisive role in disease). This was brought home to us in a clear way in the MRC study of mild hypertension treatment. To save one person from a possible future stroke, one has to treat eight hundred and fifty people unnecessarily all their lives.4 If one could imagine the drug side effects in those 850 people, one would quickly understand the doctor’s dilemma.



However, when the drug companies promote the drugs is a simplified fashion, the gullible doctor falls a prey to the falsehoods and mysteries. He/she starts prescribing drugs at the first contact. Elsewhere in this issue the details of drugless management of hypertension have been detailed. For the more discerning “scientific minded” doctor the dilemma is no less. There are more than six major guidelines in the world about the rules of the game of drug therapy of hypertension. If all of them are compiled together in a super computer, they will have covered only 31% of all hypertensives. Remaining 69% of hypertensives are not covered in this exercise. Put differently, majority (69%) of hypertension patients would not fit into the scientific standards of management!5Here we have an evidence-burdened scenario, instead of the much touted evidence-based logic.

In addition, the vested interests are trying to even refute the guidelines of their own countries, on the plea that “seven trusted specialists” there do not follow the guidelines in their practice!6



Outwith all these concerns, is the problem of pharmaco-economics in our country. We have been repeatedly stressing the importance of poverty as the basis of human ills. Hypertension is no exception here, even in the advanced countries. A study in the UK showed that the highest incidence of vascular diseases was seen in the lowest socio-economic groups! The present pre-occupation with newer drugs as first line anti-hypertensive drugs would ruin any economy, if the exchequer is to foot the bill. It is estimated that in the USA, about 50-60 million white-coat hypertensives are being treated with ACE inhibitors and Calcium channel blockers, at a phenomenal cost of 8.4 billion dollars. (Roughly three times the annual budget of India). To cap it we have the scenario where these newer drugs are yet to prove their merit in long term clinical trials.7



The stress in drug treatment has been the step-care mode of drug therapy where one starts with one drug in small doses, building the dose gradually; adding the next drug to get cumulative power to lower the pressure. We would like to call this as the step-up therapy. We have been stressing, since the early seventies, about the need to step- down therapy, wherein the doctor starts cutting down the drugs and the dosage, once he achieves the desired blood pressure levels.8 About 50% of the patients remain normo-tensives on that regime and a small percentage would need no more drugs. This could be assessed by trial and error, without detriment to the patient’s well being. As and when the pressure starts moving up, drugs could be reintroduced. Even intermittent treatment with drugs has been shown to be good enough for mild hypertensives.9 Whereas we introduced it in the seventies, it is now accepted in the West, as well.



Drugs for Treatment:



To do or not to do is the real dilemma in anti-hypertensive drug therapy.10 As has been already pointed out, all the guidelines, of which there are six organized ones, have differing advices. That makes life that much more difficult for the practising doctor. I have been in this business for well over three decades. My best advice would be to follow the following rules for the time being, till further knowledge comes in. We have the latest Joint National Committee recommendations, JNC VI of the USA,11,12 which matches most of the following suggestions:



* Diuretics and beta-blockers should be the first choice when drugs are indicated, unless there are positive indications for other drugs, or the first line drugs are contra-indicated.

* Routine treatment with drugs is recommended by the American JNC for people with sustained blood pressures above 140/90 mm.Hg, but the British recommendations put the cut off at the pressure of 160/100. Your best bet is to take a via media. Watch people in that grey zone between 140/90 and 160/100 without drugs, but with life style modifications; which are now known to be very effective.

* Indian patients respond to very small doses in the beginning. Our experience is that our patients respond to as small a dose as 10-20 mg of propranolol and/or 25 mg of hydrochlorthiazide. Potassium supplements may be needed, if hydrochlorthiazide is used alone. Some of our patients may not respond to a larger doses if used initially, without trying the small dose first!

* Although the JNC VI committee has slightly modified their stand from their own JNC V recommendations, we feel this was done at the behest of vested interests! The above recommendations meet with the approval of JNC V, JNC VI, and also the British recommendations.

* If Calcium Channel-Blockers and/ or ACE inhibitors are to be used as the first line, there must be very compelling reasons; keeping in mind the fact that we are only treating a risk factor, and not a disease and, therefore, our selection of drugs for life long use, in an apparently healthy individual, must be above all suspicion. This can not be said about the latter drugs in the setting of uncomplicated hypertension.

* When in doubt, it is better to take an opinion of the specialist in the field. This should also be done in the following special circumstances.



a) Very young or very old hypertensives detected for the first time.

b) Patients who do not respond to the ideal line of treatment, despite the fact that the patient compliance is good (resistant hypertension)

c) Hypertension with end organ damage.

d) Patients with evidence of coronary artery disease, in addition.

e) Secondary hypertensives.



The compelling reasons for using drugs other than thiazides and beta-blockers, as the first line drugs, are listed below:

* Presence of associated Diabetic Nephropathy.

* Congestive Heart failure.

* Post-myocardial Infarction.

* Systolic hypertension in the elderly.

* Presence of diseases likes Asthma, Benign Prostatic Hypertrophy, and dyslipidaemias.



The present wisdom warrants us to treat hypertensives right up to the age of 85 years.13

As has been pointed out earlier, it is safe to keep one’s options to a few well trusted drugs, as otherwise one could get into trouble with prolonged usage of the newer drugs. Labetolol is a good example. This was being advocated for use in pregnancy hypertension at one time, and was freely being used, based on theoretical considerations. Now there are reports to show how this drug could produce foetal changes in the new born babies of mothers, who have been on labetolol during pregnancy.14



The main goal of anti-hypertensive therapy is to reduce cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. This has been demonstrated for diuretics and beta-blockers very well. Other drugs should be recommended for initial therapy only if they demonstrate their capacity to do just that, without serious side effects. In that direction a new class of drugs is showing good promise, to be proved by the passage of time. AT1 blockers (Angiotensin II antagonist) could be ideal candidates. Candesartan seems to be the most efficient molecule, as far as potency goes. Other drugs are also being tried. Two important aspects of these drugs are their prolonged action, due to prolonged receptor blockage property with a peak trough ratio of more than 0.9, and the dose response curve, which shows a continuous increase in efficacy between 2mg and16 mg daily. 15



What does the future hold for us in this field? We have been in for quite a lot of disappointment in this field. The HOT study ( hypertension optimal treatment study) failed to demonstrate a significant difference between the three randomized target blood pressure groups for the majority of cardiovascular events, although it did prove the theoretical hypothesis, that more vigorous treatment could certainly bring down the measured blood pressure to greater extent, in 90% of patients! 16 Linear relationship between blood pressure and benefit does not seem to work in a dynamic system like the human body!3 This brings me back to my old and firm belief that the step-care treatment, although good for bringing down the box blood pressure, need not necessarily be good for the patient in the long run.



Gussipi Mancia, a great proponent of the step-care treatment, is slowly being converted to our view, which was being criticized by many, of step-down treatment, of using less and less drugs, as the pressures start coming down, to see if one could withdraw the drugs, at least intermittently, to lessen their side effects. “ Greater importance will be given in the future for the non-pharmacological approaches, as well as to baseline blood pressure values, at which drug treatment should be started” writes Mancia, in his recent article in the Journal of Hypertension, entitled Anti-Hypertensive treatment: Past, Present, and Future.17 We are pleased that our stand is being slowly vindicated! Ours was a plea to treat with empathy the human being with raised blood pressure, and not to target the blood pressure level, without any consideration for the human being that is labeled.







Bibliography;

1. Anderson OK, Almgren T, Persson B et. al: Survival in treated hypertensives, Follow up after two decades. BMJ 1998;317:167-171.

2. Hegde BM: Modern Trends in Anti-hypertensive Therapy. Jr.Assoc.Physi.India. 1984:32(Spl) 667-670.

3. Firth WJ: Chaos-Predicting the Unpredictable. BMJ 1991;303:1565-8.

4. MRC Study: Principal Results. BMJ 1985;291:97-104.

5. Hegde BM: Hypertension is curable. Hypertens. India 1997;11:60-64

6. Tobian L, Brunner HR, Garvas H.et.al: Modern Strategies to prevent coronary sequelae & stroke in hypertensive patients. Am. J. Hypertens. 1994; 7: 859-72.

7. Hegde BM: To do or not to do. Hypertens. India 1991;5:17-22.

8. Hegde BM, Shetty MA, Shetty MR: Hypertension–Assorted Topics 1995;Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan, Bombay.

9. Hegde BM. Chandy P K , Bhat E K: A new method of treating mild-moderate hypertension. Karnataka Med. Jr 1984;51-7-9.

10. Weber MA: Unresolved problems in treating hypertension. Am. J. Hypertens. 1998;11(10):1455-1495.

11. Kaplan NM: Insights from JNC – VI report. Am. Fam. Physician 1998;58(6):1323-30

12. Kaplan NM: The 6th Joint National Comm. Report.. Keio . J. Med 1998; 47(2):99-105.

13. Kendall MJ: Hypertension in the elderly. Basic Res. Cardiol 1998;93(suppl2):43-46.

14. Crooks BN, Deshpande 8A, Hall C et al:

Adverse Neonatal effects of maternal labetolol. Arch.Dis.Child Fetal Neonatal Ed 1998;79(2):F150-1.

15. Philip T, Heemann.U: Clinical Efficacy of a new AT1-Blocker. Basic. Res. Cardiol

1998;93 suppl 2: 51-53.

16. Chalmers J: Hot Study; a brilliant concept, but a qualified success. J Hypertens.

1998;16(10):1403-5.

17. Mancia G, Grassi G: Anti-hypertensive Treatment; Past, Present & Future. J.

Hypertens. suppl 1998;16(i):51-7.









PRINCIPLES OF DRUG THERAPY IN HYPERTENSION.













By.



Dr.(Mrs.) Meenakshi A. Shetty., MD.,

Asst. Professor of Medicine,

Kasturba Medical College,

MANGALORE



And



Professor B. M. Hegde,

Pro Vice-Chancellor,













MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION, MANIPAL-576 119.

















Comments

#1 | 241 on 1
Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/url_bbcode_include.php on line 21

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/url_bbcode_include.php on line 22

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/mail_bbcode_include.php on line 20

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/mail_bbcode_include.php on line 21

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/img_bbcode_include.php on line 20
uncover a few of exactly the same fashionable, exclusive boutique products at substantially reduce costs from wholesale sellers. Conserving funds on marriage ceremony materials provides partners additional manage more than their marriage ceremony spending budget, permitting them to own the marriage ceremony they've generally envisioned at a fraction with the expense. Within this cashstrapped economic climate knit dresses for winterknit dresses for winter , lovebirds about to just take the plunge are preparing their weddings around the inexpensive and declaring I do"to doityourself. Ahead of strolling down the aisle, a halfdozen brides and grooms will roll up their sleeves red cocktail dressesred cocktail dresses , slap on an apron, seize a squeegie and display print their very own savethedates discounted bcbg dressesdiscounted bcbg dresses , invites, location cards and thankyou notes, at a weeklong Do it yourself Marriage ceremony Workshop in the Gowanus Print Lab, Oct white wedding gownswhite wedding gowns . 1419. People have
#2 | 241 on 1
Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/url_bbcode_include.php on line 21

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/url_bbcode_include.php on line 22

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/mail_bbcode_include.php on line 20

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/mail_bbcode_include.php on line 21

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/img_bbcode_include.php on line 20
assumptions, testing them for validity iteratively until they're proven correct or incorrect christian l christian l , and identifying risks associated with each. Not validating assumptions can result in disaster. christian louboutin pumps christian louboutin pumps Here's an example . In 1999, the NASA Mars Climate Orbiter mission ended in disaster when the orbiter crashed to the surface of Mars christian louboutin boots christian louboutin boots , destroying a $125 Million taxpayer purchased scientific instrument. The assumption chrisitan louboutin chrisitan louboutin , made by a contractor design team, was that English engineering units were being used for calculations. But, the NASA engineering team was using Metric units. A simple validation would have prevented an engineering catastrophe. There are hundreds of examples of unvalidated assumptions in my career alone. I've learned, occassionally the hard way, that lessons not learned tend to repeat themselves until they are learned. miu miu shoes sale miu miu shoes sale Practice assumption analysis on all your projects. Test them for validity and periodically challenge them throughout your projects. You will
#3 | 241 on 1
Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/url_bbcode_include.php on line 21

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/url_bbcode_include.php on line 22

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/mail_bbcode_include.php on line 20

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/mail_bbcode_include.php on line 21

Deprecated: preg_replace(): The /e modifier is deprecated, use preg_replace_callback instead in /hermes/walnacweb05/walnacweb05ab/b1749/hy.manjuhegde/hegde/includes/bbcodes/img_bbcode_include.php on line 20
. lace wedding dress lace wedding dress . "rule" for marriage ceremony gown fashion will be to choose something that generates you are feeling cosy and spectacular with your most special occasion. The twenty first Century Bride - That stated . , while confident historical gown kinds are constantly well-liked evening short dresses evening short dresses . , bridal vogue does observe mainstream style to some extent. mini cocktail dresses mini cocktail dresses Thus in case you are seeking for one thing an incredibly tiny much more modern-day or "now, " ponder turning on the catwalks for inspiration. The at this time widespread 20s-and floral-style attire is going to be merely included right into a wedding ceremony gown. Add-ons, white cocktail dresses under 100 white cocktail dresses under 100 like chandelier earrings, may even transfer in the catwalks to comprise your wedding ceremony seem. Try and prevent style which will day promptly, but, as you are going

Post Comment

Please Login to Post a Comment.

Ratings

Rating is available to Members only.

Please login or register to vote.

No Ratings have been Posted.
Render time: 0.08 seconds
3,556,721 unique visits